We want to list our home,
but what if we get a lowball offer?
This is a common question I get, especially in a market like today. For the first time in many years, last week we clocked in MORE price reductions than new listings in a month. That’s a pretty significant milestone. The peak for pricing has officially passed. So what happens when a market peaks? As you know, what goes up must come down. This never takes place over night, so don’t sweat just yet.
The good news about this market cycle is we have a pretty decent blueprint of what happened during the last cycle to give insight and information.
Here are the basics:
2005 – Prices hit the peak
2008 – 2011 – These years we saw active declining in pricing (not overnight)
2012 – 2019 – These years very little changed, it was stagnant
2020 – Cycle started all over again.
Right now, I would say we are about the same as 2009. We knew there was some instability in 2023, it really started to show up in 2024 and we are very aware in 2025.
In this cycle, we may not bottom out as quickly as last cycle because the inventory levels aren’t rising like they normally would in a down cycle. So it is my prediction that the decline may take more than 3 years to occur.
All of that aside, if your plan is to “wait it out”, you need to really consider the cycle history and how long that could actually take. Spoiler alert: It’s always longer than you think. Having been through this before, I can tell you, next year is not going to be better.
So, now what? How do we get the most for the home in the current cycle? Let’s look at what the stats tell us…
The majority of homes priced well and in demand are still selling within 30 to 60 days. Pricing “higher to negotiate” will likely cost you time and money. This is not the type of market for that strategy. If you get an offer, even a low offer here’s what you want to do.
- Revisit the recent comps. Did other similar homes sell, or reduce to a level that the offer now makes a little more sense? This does happen, especially if you’ve been on the market for a while. If your agent is not keeping you up to date on this information, ask them to.
- Consider making a counteroffer anyway. It’s a tricky market with not a whole lot of certainty as to what is ahead. Do not take it personally! If you were on the buying side, you would probably be doing the same thing. Instead, look at it big picture and keep the conversation going as long as possible.
- Get creative! Sometimes, price isn’t the only issue. Is there another component of the sale you could use to gain some ground and make the offer more enticing to the buyer without cutting the price? Price is a big factor, but sometimes not even the most important one.
Now is the time to be aware that lower offers are going to be the norm. We are back to over 70% of all properties selling under asking price. That’s just where we are. It’s business, after all.
Hiring the right agent will make a big difference in your bottom line.
Let me know if I can put together a winning strategy for you!
What a difference a year makes! Long story short, there are some BIG moves that are happening. I’ve talked before about algorithmic decay. This chart here is exactly that! Little, by little, by little, then bang. That’s how markets change. Tale as old as time, song as old as rhyme, it’s almost as good as a crystal ball.
With all the insurance and septic news, I’m going to be brief on this month’s market report and just give you the numbers straight up. With only one month in, there isn’t a lot to analyze anyway.
History repeats itself. A saying I’m sure you’ve heard and said dozens of times. I might not yet be a half of a century old, but I’m old enough, and have been in this business long enough (27 years) to recognize a similar pattern. Let’s revisit the timeline of the Outer Banks real estate market from the year 2000.
What a mild winter we have had here at the beach so far. We are not complaining, that’s for sure.
