Why Selling Now Makes the Smartest Financial Sense

Every Cycle Tells the Same Story

In 2005 and 2006, we hit a major peak before the 2008 financial crisis struck. From 2008 through 2011, prices and sales activity fell sharply — and it took nearly a full decade to recover. Then came another boom from 2020 to 2022, fueled by record-low interest rates and intense buyer demand. Now, as we move through 2023–2025, we’re beginning to see familiar signs: softening demand, rising inventory, and leveling prices.

That pattern should sound familiar — because it’s the start of the next cycle.

The Psychology of the Market

We all remember that subprime mortgages triggered the 2008 crash. What’s happening now is broader — economists call it the “everything bubble.” Once bubbles begin to deflate, it typically takes four to five years to reach the bottom. The reason? Seller denial. Sellers hold out, convinced prices will bounce back, while buyers wait for better deals. In a resort market like ours, where neither side must move, both dig in.

Sellers say, “I’ll just keep it for now.”       Buyers say, “I’ll wait until prices drop.”
And who wins the waiting game? Buyers do — every time.

Key Takeaways

• The last downturn took nearly a decade to recover.
• We’re seeing early signs of another correction.
• Selling before the decline accelerates protects your equity.
• Waiting could mean competing with more sellers at lower prices — and watching your gains fade over
years, not months.

2026 Real Estate Market Prediction

Ilona Matteson - 2026 Real Estate Market ForecastReal estate markets across the country are definitely starting to crack. The northeast is really the last holdout and there are signs of a beginning surge in inventory there. With slowing activity and rising inventory, it looks like the OBX could enter a buyers market by the second quarter of next year.

Right now, our absorption rate has us at the high end of a “normal market”. Just a small increase in inventory at today’s demand level will push us over the 6-month level and right into the next category; slow market, which will favor buyers more.

Most aren’t aware of the impending foreclosure tsunami that is coming in the second quarter of 2026. On October 1st, an FHA workout program that has been in place for the last 5 years got an overhaul. Borrowers have been issued loan modifications over and over.

New guidelines in place are:

  • Only one modification every 24 months
  • Must exhibit the ability to pay the new amount for 6 months
  • Cannot be behind on student loans

FHA is reporting one million borrowers are in default at least 30 days. With these new guidelines in place, that puts a lot of homeowners in jeopardy of being foreclosed. It’s a 90 day process
that started 3 weeks ago. By January, we could start seeing these new listings hitting the market across the country.

While I don’t expect it to have a huge impact on the Outer Banks, it will start to affect markets nearby. Being a resort area, we usually get the trickle-down effect, so expect to see possibly even slower sales next year, which will contribute to higher inventory, eventually translating